I have written articles on each of the Councillors (work in progress).
In any healthy democracy, it is not only appropriate—but essential—for citizens to reflect on the performance of their elected representatives. This essay offers a considered, good-faith assessment of Shoalhaven City councillors based on publicly available information, council records, media reporting, and direct observations from council proceedings.
The views expressed here are not intended to attack individuals, but to critique public actions, decisions, and patterns of behaviour that have tangible consequences for ratepayers and the wider community. Where opinions are offered, they are clearly distinguished from matters of fact and are grounded in observable conduct such as voting records, policy positions, public statements, and meeting participation. Criticism, where made, relates strictly to a councillor’s public role, not to their personal life or character.
Every effort has been made to present information truthfully, and to ensure that commentary is fair and balanced. This essay is written in the spirit of civic engagement and democratic accountability. It is my belief that elected officials, particularly at the local level where decisions have immediate and lasting effects, should be open to scrutiny and public dialogue. That is not defamation—it is democracy. The councillor was given a pre-publication version of this article.
Should any councillor believe that something here is inaccurate or lacks context, I welcome correction. This document is not fixed in stone. Like public service itself, it benefits from transparency, feedback, and the continual pursuit of clarity. My intention is not to cause harm, but to raise the level of informed discussion about the future of our city and the conduct of those entrusted to lead it.
It is through open dialogue—not silence—that trust in public institutions is either built or eroded. This contribution, however imperfect, seeks to foster the former.Here are the links to the articles on Substack (free) as well as links to the video that I have created to to with each article:
Selena Clancy: Article Video
Peter Wilkins: Article Video
Natalee Johnston: Article Video
Matthew Norris: Article Video
Lou (Luciano) Casmiri (SIG Party Official)
Karlee Dunn: Article Video
Jason Cox: Article Video
Denise Kemp: Article Video
Ben Krikstolaitis: Article Video
Here is my rating of BEST to WORST Councillors
BEST IN ORDER: Gemma Tribe, Natalee Johnston, Gillian Boyd, Karlee Dunn, Matthew Norris, Ben Krikstolaitis
GETTING WORSE FROM THIS POINT ON - Peter Wilkins, Lou Casmiri, Jason Cox, Bob Proudfoot, Selena Clancy, Patricia White (Mayor)and complete DUDD of the bunch - Denise Kemp.
Here is my personal views on their qualities as I see it, this is my OPINION only.